Reader Bobby writes the following, regarding my post that Nicholas Sidelnik tied for first in the Swim Around Manhattan:
About your report on the “Swim around Manhattan” on the 16th of June, you have incorrectly reported the results of the race. You posted a link that took you to CNN which incorrectly stated that there was a tie for first place in that swim. That is totally wrong. I was there and I saw the finish. Steven Klugman of South Africa won by 15 feet. How is that a tie? This moron [redacted] who organized the race did not even congratulate the winner, Steven Klugman, nor did he even acknowledge that the race took place. This is a tragedy that a person flew half way around the world to compete, wins and gets no credit for it. Actually he got the credit in the NY Times that weekend but it is a crying shame that you and CNN have false reports on the finish. A very unhappy fan. Thanks, Bobby.
Guess I’ll take this one line by line.
About your report on the “Swim around Manhattan” on the 16th of June, you have incorrectly reported the results of the race. You posted a link that took you to CNN which incorrectly stated that there was a tie for first place in that swim. That is totally wrong.
I apologize for not knowing about the 15-foot difference, but I got my information from CNN, which is usually a reputable source, so you can hardly blame me for believing their article.
I was there and I saw the finish. Steven Klugman of South Africa won by 15 feet. How is that a tie?
It isn’t. But you should really contact the primary source of this information; I’m a secondary source, which means I just repeated what I read.
This moron [redacted] who organized the race did not even congratulate the winner, Steven Klugman, nor did he even acknowledge that the race took place.
The man who organized the race didn’t acknowledge that it took place? Sounds like he deserves a good email rebuking, too. Strange that someone would go to such lengths to organize an event, and then either not show or not acknowledge that it occurred. Someone should give him a lesson in PR.
This is a tragedy that a person flew half way around the world to compete, wins and gets no credit for it.
I save the word tragedy for war, death, and the like. It is a shame, perhaps even a crying shame, but I don’t think it was a tragedy.
Actually he got the credit in the NY Times that weekend
Ah, then it isn’t a tragedy. Whew.
but it is a crying shame that you and CNN have false reports on the finish.
Again, sorry. But the beef is with CNN (and, apparently, Mr. [redacted]). I just reported what I read on one of the world’s biggest and most respected news sites. Surely I can be forgiven for trusting the CNN name.
A very unhappy fan.
Hey, at least he’s a fan.
Thanks, Bobby.
You’re welcome?
The reason I even posted this was because I had interviewed Sidelnik five days before the race. No offense to Mr. Klugman, but I never would have heard of him if I hadn’t googled Nicholas Sidelnik’s name after turning in my video package on his quest to swim the English Channel. Considering the inconsequential scope of the complaint (especially on this 50-hit-a-day blog) and the vehement insistence that first place should not be shared, I think we have our second example of Hornstining.