In 1999, Boston University professor John Schulz gave a lecture in a COM 101 class that included some quotes from Nation magazine. Unfortunately, Mr. Schulz failed to accurately attribute the quotes (quite unintentionally; possibly because class time was quickly waning), and, when an 18-year-old student posted Schulz’s mistake on the class message board, a firestorm ensued. Schulz was forced to resign his post as chairman of his department.
In 2002, BU President Jon Westling was quickly forced to leave office, after the BU Board of Trustees (and John “the one-armed bandit” Silber) decided they wanted someone else running the school. In a complete coincidence, Silber gave up his post as Chancellor (not that any students know what he does) and became the de facto President. It was, more or less, as if Batista had come back in 1975 to overthrow Castro. Westling decided to take a one-year sabbatical, after which he claimed he would return to teach. Meanwhile, Silber’s rule continues.
Earlier this month, Silber asked College of Communications Dean Brent Baker to step down, partially due to his views that the COM curriculum should include more liberal arts and less professional study. Silber also wanted (and I fully support this) to upgrade COM 101, the biggest waste of a class BU has. Baker initially resigned, intending to take a one-year sabbatical (possibly to the same vacation spot as Westling), and then returning to teach in 2004. Meanwhile, at a COM staff meeting, Film/TV department head Bill Lawson decried the actions of Silber and his cronies H. Joachim Maitre and BU professor Keith Botsford, calling them “a cabal of misfits,” garnering applause from those in attendance. Ironically, Maitre was forced to resign (and was replaced by Baker) when he failed to site sources in a commencement address. The difference between him and Schulz is that he was given adequate time to prepare and cite his speech, plus there was no time limit. Either way, Lawson was relieved of his duties as department head, and has been asked to resign. So far, he has resisted the latter suggestion.
So as bad as it was for Silber to just force Baker out, Baker’s commencement speech at the COM graduation nine days ago hastened his exit. He quoted from Silber’s Limbaugh-esque book “Straight Shooting” (a copy of which was given to all graduating BU seniors this year as a graduation present; I’m happy I got a clock instead), which claims that the best way for a dean to stick around is to “keep his head down.” Baker further read, and I quote, “A corrollary must also be noted; deans may lose their jobs and be undone precisely because they have done their jobs exceedingly well.” It’s pretty obvious he considered himself to fall into that latter category. In addition, Associate Dean Marilyn Root shocked everyone at graduation by announcing her own retirement, a decision that stemmed from the Baker situation. Well, Silber and his thugs found out, and kicked Baker out of the COM building within a week. And who is replacing him? Well none other than John Schulz, the man whose department head position was taken away four years ago.
I wasn’t a big fan of Baker, and was fairly indifferent toward Root (I like Lawson), but nobody should be treated the way they were. Silber and his, yes, cabal of misfits are prohibiting the freedom to dissent in a way not seen since…well, since last month, actually. As stupid as I feel the “ban the liberals” movement has been, I think the recent situation surrounding the College of the Communication is just as reprehensible. And lest anyone think I’m drawing a false analogy between the War in Iraq and the COM debacle, or even overstating the import of what has happened, at least I’m not as bad as Botsford, who claims that, “Academic warfare is quite worse than anything that happened in Iraq.” Somebody stop him before his head causes a solar eclipse.
Thanks to the Boston Globe for printing such an informative article, and to Georgiana Cohen for giving me a first-hand account of the COM graduation ceremony.