Every week, Joe Morgan holds a baseball chat on ESPN.com. And every week I read through the chat wrap and don’t know whether to laugh or cry at what he’s saying. The man is so biased toward the “Big Red Machine” of the 70s you can smell it over the Internet. He dismisses any sort of statistics that can’t be computed with an old-fashioned slide rule. And, twice in the past week, he has insulted Billy Beane for having written “Moneyball.” There’s one big problem with this: as Aaron Gleeman complained on May 26th, Billy Beane didn’t write a single word of the book!
When you’re a baseball “expert” and you have no clue about who wrote the most hyped (and possibly most important) sports book of the past decade, you should not be commenting on it. Here is what Morgan said last week:
I read an excerpt in the NY Times. It’s typical if you write a book, you want to be the hero. That is apparently what Beane has done.
(This is, by the way, what Morgan did in his own book.) Since apparently nobody at ESPN.com corrected him, and he didn’t go out of his way to learn the truth, here’s what he said today (in addition to throwing three thinly-veiled digs Beane’s way in the span of 60 minutes):
I wouldn’t be Billy Beane first of all!! I wouldn’t write the book Moneyball!
If Morgan really read the New York Times review, he should at least have come away with the knowledge that Michael Lewis wrote the book. But I guess mixing up a book’s main character and its writer is a common occurrence for Joe. After all, he’s listed as the main author for his autobiography.
In recent weeks, Morgan has also claimed that Red Sox pitching coach Tony Cloninger hit “a lot” of grand slams in his career (truth: Cloninger hit two–both in the same game), that he “doesn’t know” whether Greg Maddux pitched longer for the Braves or Cubs (with the Cubs: 5 full seasons; with the Braves, he’s going on eleven), and that the Boston Red Sox have a “bullpen by committee.” Well, hell, Joe. What team doesn’t? Is there really a team out there that has a one-man bullpen? Or is Joe Morgan talking out of his “expert” ass?
If I wanted to know what it’s like to stare down Tom Seaver when you’re down 0-2 in the count, I’d ask Joe Morgan. If I want someone to teach my 5′7″ hypothetical son how to hit a curveball or backhand a grounder up the middle, Morgan’s my man. Hell, if I needed another team to wipe the floor with in my fantasy baseball league, Morgan’s high on the list. But if I want an intellectual discussion devoid of cliches like “he knows how to win” or “veteran leadership,” you can’t get me far enough away from the Big Red Machine’s little round cog.