Black Unlike Me
Sunday, October 6th, 2002The current flap over anti-black leader comments in the movie “Barbershop” makes no sense whatsoever. Jesse Jackson may think he is doing the black community a favor by protesting against the scene insulting Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King, Jr., and himself, but he is really just showing his ignorance and fragile ego. During the scene in question, one character says Rosa Parks got more publicity than other blacks who refused to give up bus seats due to her position in the NAACP (true: she was a secretary there and there were other blacks who refused to stand on the bus–some who did so before Rosa Parks–that aren’t in our history books), that Martin Luther King, Jr. cheated on his wife many times (true), that Rodney King deserved to get beaten up (not true: nobody deserves to be beaten, but if King hadn’t kept coming at officers after being hit by a tranquilizer, he wouldn’t have been in so much trouble), and, to top things off, “f— Jesse Jackson.”
Jackson further undermines his position by requesting that ALL video rental chains that carry the film delete the lines in question. This is patently ridiculous. First, the character who speaks the controversial lines is roundly taken to task by the rest of the characters in the barbershop. Second, far worse things have been said about blacks in movies (Mississippi Burning, Glory, Malcolm X, etc.), and Jackson hasn’t asked these movies to cut dialogue. Granted, none of these movies have insulted Jesse personally. Third, the First Amendment protects the rights of people to say whatever they want–including fictional people who are given these lines to make a point–a point Jackson missed completely. Fourth, the black community as a whole has much worse problems than a critically-acclaimed movie. Why isn’t Jackson making a big stink about these issues? Fifth, BET does more harm to the black community than anything else in America. Its videos full of “booty dancers,” drugs, and money further stereotypes of blacks more than any racist, KKK-inspired propaganda. As an experiment recently, I turned BET on ten times in a day. Six times I found videos featuring booties, drugs, or money/cars/bling-bling. Three times commercials were on. Only once did I turn to BET and find any sort of news or information being disseminated.
Jesse is an example of a larger problem–people and groups criticizing movies without having seen them or taking them in context. Bob Dole famously railed against “Pulp Fiction” and “Trainspotting” (which include fewer than 10 deaths combined) even though he hadn’t–and probably still hasn’t–seen either film. Of course, he never chastised any Arnold “If I’m a Republican, Why Can’t I Make Money on a Movie-Themed Restaurant?” Schwarzenegger films, any number of which are much more violent and contain much more death. From “South Park” (if your 12-year-old is quoting an R-rated movie, it’s your own damn fault for not monitoring them) to “Trainspotting” (if any movie has argued against heroin use, it’s this one), people pick and choose scenes rather than looking at the whole picture (pun partially intended).
Another larger problem this brings up is the labelling of anything that’s not pro-minority “racist” or “sexist” or “whatever-ist.” While racism/sexism/etc. are large problems in this country, far too much gets blamed on them. Sometimes the non-black person is better for the job; sometimes the black person is better. Sometimes the non-female is more deserving of the scholarship; some times the female is more deserving. Sometimes senior citizens are terrible drivers; sometimes they aren’t. But those who blame everything that doesn’t go their way on the innate prejudice of those making the decisions are further in denial than anyone should ever be.